Site Overlay


DEFINING. DEVIANCY. Do,l. How We’ve Become Accustomed to Alarming Levels. Of Crime and Destructive Behavior. BY DANIEL PATRICK MOYNIHAN. Pat Moynihan, the great politician-intellectual, warned about the dangers of ” defining deviancy down,” in which worse and worse behavior. NEW YORK CITY — The late Sen. Daniel Patrick Moynihan caught the decline of the culture two decades ago, observing that we’re “defining.

Author: Kazrashakar Faulkree
Country: Rwanda
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: History
Published (Last): 18 January 2012
Pages: 117
PDF File Size: 19.96 Mb
ePub File Size: 20.36 Mb
ISBN: 633-2-53203-561-3
Downloads: 11233
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Baktilar

Seth, this is a fantastic and very complex and well-thought out post. Rituals are granted gravity by the respect of a wider circle of people or the recognition of people hierarchically superior to you. Moynihan also insists on drawing a direct correalation between single parent families and violent crime, relying heavily on anecdotes to sway his audience. Put your money where your mouth is, and done good. That’s deviacy I think. Dfining addition to horrifically unsanitary conditions, he is charged with the death of at least one patient and murdering seven babies born alive after botched abortions.

Defining Deviancy Down

Classes in definign are proliferating because they teach how to focus on the intellectually important. Tomorrow’s moved and kicked, that’s who. What was your title at the Department of Labor? We had to demonstrate how separate schools were inherently unequal.

Let me go back just a bit, in terms of what has happened in this century.

That seems like sloppy thinking. We forget how free that earlier world was. The quibble I have here is that corporate behaviour is not individual behaviour, so perhaps a different set of criteria are necessary to describe it I think the criticism that this was a bad post has mostly come from one person.

I will argue that this is a bad FPP because it is essentially contentless. Following an appreciative applause he repeated it and got a standing ovation. This is a damn fine post and an even better response to the valid criticism that seth was complaining about front page posts without ever having made one. It shows one writer’s counter-argument. Becker details the process of how these deviant outsiders become involved in secondary deviance.


I know that that sounds like special pleading and weakens …. Like the drug users before them, smokers tend to be from the lower end of the socioeconomic spectrum, with less education, income and political power than those labeling them.

I never saw any action at sea.

Defining deviancy down essay

What makes that a bad thing in itself? Sure; difficult for any child. Aren’t you effectively using a perspective inside your own cultural context to justify selecting that as the cultural context to spread? In the great Civil Rights Act was passed.

The standards we are discussing are the standards of the blue, not some abstract moral standards in society, or perhaps not. But in that unemployment rate, black unemployment was well below white unemployment, because blacks were on farms, and on a farm you may have, you know, scarcely enough to live on, but you are employed. They had to break the bookshelf open because it had slid down inside I mean, that’s when this new paradigm started.

Defining deviancy down – Washington Times

And well, my party, I fear, was scandalized. It indicates sloppy thinking. The earlier, once-scorned Eastern Europeans have pretty well gone through this assimilation melting pot, haven’t they?

But alas, they are not. Oh, you know who smokes out of all proportion to their numbers in the society — it is the people standing in your criminal courtrooms, that’s who. It occurred to me that what we had been doing in the last 30 years was that, as we got too much deviant behavior, we began to define it down.


I mean, Frank Fukuyama’s new book, basically, called The Great Disruptionfor example, makes the case that both of those things happened; this great disruption on the social side happened, and starting in the late s or the early s, we have rebounded on the socials — not far enough — but crime is down, welfare is down.

Column by Krauthammer, which deviancg described as ‘now-famous’– I already noted that his intitial paragraph is disproved by Odwn you go on to say that Krauthammer posits that deviancy can be ‘defined up’. In that light, I find this all interesting and even amusing, but I don’t take it personally. And links stitched together by quotes from context, at that.

That’s how brief they were.

Defining Deviancy Down | MetaFilter

Yes, they have, but without losing certain identities which seem to pass on from generation to generation, some of which grow intensified. I would be bold enough to assert this. Fools rush in, indeed. People like us make the rules for people like them.

We’re quieting defibing on these things. One is this incredible, unexpected economic growth and stability. But, the ax being ground was provided economically enough and the discussion was good, I’ll grant you that. Howard Becker’s approach to the labeling of deviance, as described in Outsiders: And people shouldn’t think this is a balanced post because it refers to Moynihan’s theory, and has a lot of links attached.

Anyway, onto the other links: Movers and kickers, that’s who.